| Year | Recipient | Degree/Grad Year | Award Name |
| 2023 | Kimi Blewett | BS '12 | Athletic Hall of Fame |
| 2023 | J.R. Cipra | BS '01 | Athletic Hall of Fame |
| 2023 | Katie (Weininger) Kuhn; | BA '09 | Athletic Hall of Fame |
| 2023 | Stu Levine | BS '65 | Athletic Hall of Fame |
| 2023 | Luke Miller | BS '11 | Athletic Hall of Fame |
| 2023 | Jackie (Mangola) Price | BS '12 | Athletic Hall of Fame |
| 2021 | Matthew Ellis | BSME '03 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2021 | Wesley Hostetler | BS '06 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2021 | Christina (Mangola) Martinez | BA '10 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2021 | Elizabeth (Schnelle) Watson | BSBA '10 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2021 | Kate Witte | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 2019 | Danielle (Noe) Otte | BS '09 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2019 | Diana (Smith) Schnipke | BS '07 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2019 | Richard Bowersock | BA '75 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2019 | James O'Brien | BSME '09 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2018 | Karlee (Kanuckel) Badenhop | BSBA '07 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2018 | Karen (Lee) Budd | BS '05 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2018 | Mike Kluse | BSBA '00 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2018 | Matt Tepe | BSBA '91 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2017 | Ann Ringler Bassitt | BS '97 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2017 | Lauren (Ernst) Gillot | BS '07 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2017 | Joe Maiani | BA '97 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2017 | Jason Trusnik | BA '07 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2016 | Ed Chessar | BSPH '93 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2016 | Kristen Hancock | BSEE '89 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2016 | Dave King | BA '74 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2016 | Megan (Earley) Sargent | PHARMD '04 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2015 | Jackie Dight | BS '03 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2015 | Kristen Barron-May | BS '97 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2015 | David Grantier | BSME '88 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2015 | William Lang | BA '75 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2014 | Jackie (Kaup) Briscoe | PHARMD '04 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2014 | Hannah (Kanuckel) Creager | BSBA '05 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2014 | Erin Hipp-Hester | BSPH '99 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2014 | Jim Conrad | BSBA '04 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2014 | Kris Oberdick | BA '02 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2014 | Jamal Robertson | BA | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2013 | Alisa (Dentinger) Agozzino | BA '01 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2013 | Dr. DeBow Freed | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 2013 | Theresa L. Krach | BSBA '88 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2013 | Jesse L. Marlow | BSBA '83 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2012 | Brandi Nicole (Stover) Bruns | BA '02 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2012 | Beth Ann (Breudigam) Gribler | BSBA '85 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2012 | Nancy Jean (Shoemaker) Keith | BA '89 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2012 | Robert Garner Lydic | BS '97 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2012 | John Martin Wechter | BSPH '78 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2011 | Sandra (Hoying) Paeltz | BS, BSMT '00 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2011 | Benjamin Shaffer | BSPH '99 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2011 | James Shaw | BSCE '87 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2011 | Karla (Thobe) Siereveld | BS '96 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2011 | Jeremy Thompson | BSBA '00 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2011 | Mandy (Miller) Yates | PHARMD '02 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2010 | Gina L. Fall | BA '96 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2010 | Amy (Wood) Mills | BS '96 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2010 | Thomas P. Perkins | BA '95 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2010 | Maryann C. Rist | BSBA '96 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2010 | John C. Smith | BA '74 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2010 | Kevin J. Sensabaugh | BA '99 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2009 | Lori Kane | BSBA '85 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2009 | James Ricketts | BSED '60 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2009 | Brad Rogers | BSME '90 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2009 | Mary Bouic Schmidt | BSPH '94 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2009 | Cortney Roof Simpson | BA '98 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2009 | Matthew Wolf | BSPH '98 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2008 | Cari Treisch Bahmer | BA '98 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2008 | Nicholas Bertke | BS '97 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2008 | Christina Rutledge Crook | BA '88 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2008 | Cary Gunning Hartness | BSPH '98 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2008 | Edward Miklavcic | BSME '76 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2008 | Stanley Reineke | BS, BSBA '88 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2007 | Kelly Born Carbone | BS '89 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2007 | D'Artis Jones | BSME '97 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2007 | Dawn Hill Kock | BS, BSMT '91 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2007 | Laura Pruchnicki | BA '97 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2007 | Brent Ridenour | BSBA '95 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2007 | Richard Trick | BSED '64 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2006 | Kerry Barnett | BSBA '95 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2006 | Jennifer Bird-Duff | BSBA '95 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2006 | Mark Gooden | BSEE '95 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2006 | Bruce Hays | BSED '71 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2006 | Mary Ann Hockett | BSBA '92 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2006 | Robert Irvin | BSED '52 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2005 | Michael Dasher | BA '68 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2005 | Derek Dickinson | BSED '67 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2005 | Ronald Evans | BSED '57 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2005 | Joanne Roebuck Petty | BA '83 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2005 | William L. Robinson | BSED '61 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2005 | Deantha Budde Schuman | BSPH '92 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2005 | Greta Theilking Sweney | BSPH '88 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2004 | Lawrence C. Barrett | BA, BSBA '71 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2004 | Rick Jobe | BA '86 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2004 | Sara Stewart Rhymer | BA '91 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2004 | Amy Cormier Shuttleworth | BSPH '94 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2004 | Melinda Everhart Simpson | BSEE '90 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2004 | Dale Strahm | BSED '66 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2002 | Brenda K. Bowers | BA '87 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2002 | Roxanna Karg | BA '79 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2002 | Floyd Keith | BSED '70 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2002 | Mark Lenssen | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 2002 | Claude A. Stober | BSED '53 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2002 | Marcia M. Walters | BSEE '87 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2001 | Christy Wagner Beaschler | BSBA, MBA '87 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2001 | Vincent Cameron | BSPh '91 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2001 | William Croy | BA '71 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2001 | Ann Lightner | BSEd '73 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2001 | Jeff Steinberg | BA '65 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2001 | Ann Swerzler Taylor | BSPh '89 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2000 | Gordon Acheson | BSEd, DBA '57 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2000 | Douglas Burton | BSBA '78 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2000 | Stacey Hairston | BS '89 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2000 | Melinda Durbin Hileman | BA '89 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2000 | Jill Jolliff | BA '89 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 2000 | Mozelle Pickering | BSEd '35 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1999 | Dr. Amar Bhattacharya | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 1999 | Melanie Braidich | BSBA '85 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1999 | Dennis Jasinski | BSEd '68 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1999 | Robin Patterson | BS '85 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1999 | Melvin Peters | BSEd '65 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1999 | Charlene Smith Shoup | BA '88 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1998 | Nancy Emerick | BA '88 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1998 | Jeneane Des Combes Lesko | BA '57 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1998 | Jacque Strahley | BA '85 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1998 | Gerald Stechschulte | BSEd '66 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1998 | Donald Thomas | BA '75 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1998 | James Van DeGrift | BSEd '61 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1997 | Eric Batt | BSCE '83 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1997 | Alicia Bell | BA '80 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1997 | Joe Campoli | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 1997 | Jo Cook (Laurie) | BA '74 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1997 | Charlie Just | BA '77 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1997 | Carol Modica | BA '84 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1996 | Julie Lenhart | BA '80 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1996 | Stanley D. Mories | BSBA '82 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1996 | Denise Callahan | BSPh '84 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1996 | Darren W. Scott | BS '87 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1996 | O. Glenn Smith | BSME '56 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1996 | Lavelle Steinke Smith | BA '72 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1995 | Woodrow W. Bailey | BSEd '37 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1995 | Mariann Heals Condrat | BA '74 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1995 | Charles E. Dasher | BSPh '65 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1995 | John W. Emerson | BSME '69 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1995 | Vicki Mauk | BA '81 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1995 | Debra Shondrick | BA '75 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1994 | Mike Becraft | BA '80 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1994 | Gale Daugherty | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 1994 | Vicki Felver | BSEd '72 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1994 | Gayle Lauth | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 1994 | Tracy Love | BSPh '57 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1994 | Linda Maurer | BA '78 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1993 | Anne L. Coon | BSEd '69 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1993 | Alan H. Donhoff | BA '77 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1993 | Deb L. Herbert | BA '74 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1993 | Joe L. Miller | BSEd '61 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1993 | William N. Shunkwiler | BSEd '52 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1993 | Polly A. Wilkes | BA '79 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1992 | John W. Banyas | BSEd '39 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1992 | Sandra Beichler | BSPh '74 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1992 | George C. Hindall | BSBA '33 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1992 | Shirley Moody Keiner | BSEd '60 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1992 | Roxanna Grist Laycox | BSEd '71 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1992 | Henry C. Miller | BSEd '49 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1991 | Bettye Jo Hansbarger | BSEd '65 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1991 | Damon Infalvi | BSBA '70 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1991 | Sheila Wallace Kovalchik | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 1991 | James Seckman | BSEd '61 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1991 | Gary Warner | BSEd '65 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1990 | Andra Bell | BA '73 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1990 | Tom Hollman | BSEd '68 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1990 | D. Ross Irons | BSPh '55 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1990 | Sue Mullins | BSEd '65 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1990 | Collins Stackhouse | BSEd '46 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1990 | Margaret Williams | BA '77 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1989 | Michael G. Kobilarcsik | BSEd '66 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1989 | Helen Spar Ludwig | BSEd, DPE '44 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1989 | Maurice A. Pfeifer | BSEd '59 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1989 | Donald E. Skelly | BSEd '58 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1988 | Lawrence H. Archer | BSCE '47 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1988 | Thomas E. Greer | BSEd '65 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1988 | Thomas F. Pokorosky | BSEd '34 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1988 | David J. Schmelzer | BSEd '56 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1987 | John V. McDowell | BSPh '53 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1987 | Dr. James D. Thullen | BSPh '63 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1987 | Allen T. Willoughby | BSEd '51 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1986 | Alfred C. Carrino | BSPh '51 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1986 | Arthur W. Wiles | JD '27 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1986 | Nelson H. Lauless | BSEd '47 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1985 | Norman C. Bray | BSEd '42 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1985 | Ronald E. Holtrey | BSEd '62 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1985 | Casimir P. Newdome | BSEd '38 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1984 | Lonnie Norris | BSEd '62 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1984 | James Glase | BSEd '50 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1984 | Chun "C.C." Lee | BSME, D ENGR '27 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1983 | Jerry English | BSEd '64 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1983 | Herbert Strayer | BS '62 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1983 | Clyde Quinby | BSEd '61 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1982 | Morris Greene | BSPh '36 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1982 | George Blose | BSEd '37 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1982 | James Brentlinger | BSEd '37 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1982 | Maurice Shingler | BSEd '47 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1981 | Harry Winters | BSEd '40 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1981 | Fred Church | BSEd '49 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1981 | Dan Foster | BA '69 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1980 | Paul Feinerer | BSEd '40 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1980 | William Hayden | BSEd '50 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1980 | Bruno Mallone | BSEd '42 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1979 | Eugene "Skip" Baughman | BSEd '53 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1979 | George Killian | BSEd '49 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1979 | Robert Rupert | BSEd '52 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1978 | Joe Ayers | BA '36 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1978 | Charles Ash | BSEd '37 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1978 | Louis Nemec | BSEd '38 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1978 | Angelo Jannotti | BSEd '43 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1978 | Lowell Shaffer | BSEd '46 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1978 | Charles Heck | BSEd '49 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1977 | Jack Decker | BSEd '53 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1977 | William E. Peterson | BSEd '47 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1977 | Kenneth Shoemaker | BSEd '43 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1976 | Clare Stump Sr. | BSEE '14 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1976 | Ramon Harmon | BSEd '37 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1976 | Alfred Robinson | BSEd '38 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1975 | Arden Roberson | BSEd '49 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1975 | Elmer Faber | BS '39 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1975 | Richard Long | BSEd '30 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1975 | Phil Shipe | BA '34 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1974 | Joe Banks | BSEd '41 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1974 | Bernard S. Miller | BSCE '22 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1974 | Jimmie Stahl | BSEd '56 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1974 | Charles Strasbaugh | BSEd '50 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1973 | Joe Thomas | BSEd, DBA '43 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1973 | Charles V. Mather | BSEd '37 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1973 | John Allen | BA '32 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1972 | Marvin V. English | BSEd, D PE '41 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1972 | Harris A. Lamb | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 1972 | R. Lowell Reese | BA '35 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1971 | William P. Arthur | BSEd '51 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1971 | D. Ray Baum | BS '28 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1971 | Nils O. Melkerson | BSCE '31 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1970 | Frank J. Adler | BSME '24 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1970 | Frank P. Haley | BA '25 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1970 | William E. Kair | BSCE '21 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1970 | George A. Keel | BSEd '41 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1970 | Joseph P. Mallone | BSEd, JD '39 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1970 | A. Ross Siverling | JD '33 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1969 | Jerry L. Katherman | BS '21 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1969 | Clifford Kershner | BS '25 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1969 | Clyde A. Lamb | Athletic Hall Of Fame | |
| 1969 | John S. Manion | BSCE '18 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1969 | C.V. "Red" Money | BSEd '28 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1969 | Von Spellman | LLB '24 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1968 | Russell J. Anspach | BSME, BSEE '26 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1968 | E. Paul Lynch | LLB | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1968 | Harry S. Siegel | LLB '21 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1968 | Albert N. Smith | BSBA '24 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1968 | Thomas J. Smull | BSME, BSCE, D ENGR '04 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |
| 1968 | Ronald W. Wander | BSCE, D ENGR '24 | Athletic Hall Of Fame |